There is a saying, usually attributed to African culture that says “it takes a village to raise a child.” Hilary Clinton borrowed it for the title of her book published in 1996. In it she says “All of us, whether we acknowledge it or not, are responsible for deciding whether our children are raised in a nation that doesn’t just espouse family values but values families and children.”
All of us, Hilary says. That includes all generations, all genders, parents and non parents. We all have role in raising the children of our nation. I have been dismayed to see that in the two editions of RTE Primetime that to date have discussed the crèche situation following the broadcast of ‘Breach of Trust’ have had all female panels. This may give the impression that childcare is just a women’s issue, which is clearly not the case. It is not even just a parental issue. The care of our youngest and most vulnerable citizens is something we all should have an interest in. Even if you hate children please remember they are our future. They will be paying our pensions.
I welcome the current discussion we are having as a result of the excellent expose by RTE’s investigative unit. However I am dismayed by the regular (almost constant) linking of this debate with working parents and working mothers in particular. Childcare should be about what is best for the child. If we continually link the issue of full time care with the issue of women in the workforce we are doing our children a grave disservice.
One of the possible reasons that we have had the explosion in recent years of the ‘industrial’ (for the want of a better word) type crèche businesses is that society (our village) seems to want a custodial arrangement for children where they are fed, watered, changed and rested while their parents are at work. These kind of crèches are fine in shopping centres where older little ones (usually they must be toilet trained) are can be dropped off for a hour or two while their carer does some shopping. But I am very unsure that the crèches such as the type we saw in Breach of Trust provide what is best for our children, especially the very young.
I don’t say that lightly. I am a mother of three and all of my children attended crèches – full time for varying lengths of time. When my eldest was born I was a single parent living at home with my parents. So I didn’t have the option of having someone coming into my house. Therefore it was either a child minder or a crèche. I chose a crèche.
Anyone who has cared for small children will know what a difficult job it is. It is emotionally, physically and psychologically testing and at times it is mind numbingly boring. I know I sometimes snapped at my kids when I shouldn’t have. I have shouted. I may have even cursed. But like most parents I imagine, when that happened I was always so horrified and so immediately full of remorse that I usually then smothered said child in affection. Something I didn’t see happen in the Primetime programme.
But it was precisely because I know how difficult looking after small kids is that I thought a bigger environment where they were not at the ‘mercy’ of just one minder would provide a safer environment. But towards the end of my time using a crèche I began to feel that maybe I was wrong.
I hadn’t factored in the segregation of the children in large crèches. In my experience these crèches have a baby room, a wobbler room, a toddler room and Montessori room etc. This clearly makes it easier for the staff to manage but I am not convinced it’s best for the children. It also means that these very young children can be spending up to 10 or 11 hours in the one room. This is not healthy. In fact one of the final straws that broke my own particular camel’s back was that my youngest (who was about 9 months) kept getting repeated ear infections. After her third burst eardrum I asked our consultant what I could proactively do to avoid further infection. He looked me straight in the eye and said “take her out of the crèche.”
At the time I nearly thumped him. How very dare he? I was exhausted from working full time, with three kids (one a teenager and two pre schoolers in fulltime day care) but I loved my children and was doing my best. I was very sensitive to criticism.
As I sat in his office, in shock, trying to contain to urge to run, he calmly told me that very young children’s immune systems are not strong enough to cope with being in a close environment with other ‘stranger’ children of the same age. “There’s a reason children don’t start school till after 3 years” he said.
So if I had to make decisions about the care of my precious babies again I would probably plump for a good childminder. A woman who could preferably come into my home or if not whose home I felt was a cosy, warm, safe domestic environment where I would be happy to spend a day.
I interviewed David Coleman some time ago and I raised this question as to what care is best for our children. He was unequivocal in his response. “I think that it is way better for children to have a parent at home. I say that because, with the best will in the world no one is going to be able to care for your child with the same level of unconditionality as you do.” He went on to say it is a difficult role and not one that suits everyone “it’s got to be fulfilling for whoever is staying at home and if it’s not, then don’t do it.”
Of course not everyone has the full of plethora of childcare choices available to them and David readily admits that. But in a perfect world where all things were equal the second best option, he says is having a childminder come to your home followed by your child going to their home. Crèche and ‘leaving it all to an au pair’ complete the list in order of least ideal options. But David does stress that it’s all about the quality of care – you may have a great childminder or crèche leader which could work out very well for you and your child. And he reminds me “children are very resilient”
So as we continue this hugely important debate can we focus on the children and their needs and not those of working parents. Can we question if a large crèche with children separated into zones is really the best thing for our very youngest children. And most of all can we remember we all have a responsibility to our youngest citizens.
Yes I do believe it takes a village to raise a child. Our community is led by our politicians who we have voted into power. We have a Minister for Children. We had a referendum on children’s rights just last year. But I am not sure that our government have accepted the old African wisdom on childraising. I am not sure that they feel they have a responsibility to spend some of our money on ensuring that whatever option parents decide is best, that the care our children get is the very best and nothing short of that.
I think Hilary Clinton was dead right when she said “Children are not rugged individualists. They depend on the adults they know and on thousands more who make decisions every day that affect their well-being.”
We need to keep talking, we as working parents need to curb our extra sensitivity to perceived criticism, we need to keep searching for the best answers and to keep listening to each other and to our children. Then we need to demand that childcare services are properly funded.
Working mothers guilt has stopped this conversation from ever happening.
I have worked in creches but would never send my own child to one. Not because I have ever witnessed what was shown on prime time but as it is just not a realistic setting or environment for a child to be for 10 hours a day.
The routine for a childcarer is intense, cleaning is a huge part, don't get me wrong hygiene is important but staff rotate to clean the staff toilets & kitchen etc. While this is happening it means a staff member is gone from the room.
The ratios just don't work, in fact how could they ever work?
A lot of comment has been made that there was lack of management at these creches, what a joke, that's exactly where the pressure on staff comes from.
A child wandering the room as they don't want to sit down at a table to do a curriculum( god give me strength- a toddler adhering to a curriculum), if a manager walks in the room, the first thing that happend is the staff is blamed for not getting the child to sit like the others. Also why were the girls featured falsifying documents? Pressure from management!
Creches just don't work, Montessori & Pre-schools do as they are for 3 to 4 hours a day. There has been a big call for staff now to have degrees, seriously as someone who has spent 12 years working in various childcare settings I can tell you it is not rocket science. Theory is important but in childcare, kindness, sympathy & a huge dose of cop'on are the most important attributes to have.
Mothers and fathers need to be supported if they want to stay at home, childminders are the next best thing and do you know why? They are not regulated, no health & safety madness!
A well written, honest and insightful post, as always. Is it time perhaps to abandon the lazy solutions of 'blame the government' and 'bring in more regulation' and look at the values that we take for granted? We look back on previous centuries with horror at the sight of ethnic slavery. What will future centuries make of our own economic slavery – often self imposed through mortgages and consumerism? I wonder is it time to imagine a different world? I wonder.